“The Christmas Tree Controversy”

There are times when I don’t know whether to laugh out loud or just grieve quietly over some of the biblical ignorance and spiritual negligence of some preachers. Today was one of those days when I just shook my head while I listened to one of our local pastors spend an hour on a call-in radio program making the case that having a Christmas tree in your house or house of worship is idolatry. His sincerity outdistanced his logic. His dogma was made all the more dangerous when he based his opinion on one passage of Scripture.  Anytime you seek to establish a “truth” you should have at least two to three biblical witnesses to establish the spiritual precedence (Matthew 18:16).

“The Christmas Tree Controversy” is rooted out of a wrong interpretation of biblical language and a misunderstanding of ancient customs. The scripture passage that this pastor chose to use to support his “anti-Christmas tree” position is Jeremiah 10:1-5. This passage uses the following language in the King James Version, “For the customs of the people are vain: for one cutteth a tree out of the forest, the work of the hands of the workman, with the axe. They deck it with silver and with gold; they fasten it with nails and hammers, that it move not” (vss.3-4). This was explained and exclaimed as proof positive that Christmas trees are pagan and anyone in possession of one was engaged in idol worship.

Please allow me to offer context and clarity to the Jeremiah 10:1-5 text. This passage is a word of warning to the “house of Israel” to not participate in idol worship. “The way of the heathen” is idolatry. This idolatry can be witnessed in how the unsaved allow the “signs of the heavens” to control their perspective of life. This would be referring to the wrong use of astrology. All astrology is not evil.  God orchestrated astrology to be used by the wise men to locate Jesus (Matthew 2:9-10).

There is also a warning against idolatry that comes in the form of images that are crafted from earthy materials, like wood. This is the reference to, “the customs of the people“.  The customs included going into the forest, selecting a tree, returning with it in order to have an artisan cut the trunk or the stock of the tree to create an image that would be worshipped as a deity.

“The work of the hands of the workman” is not describing cutting down a tree with an axe, but rather using a sharp chisel to fashion a piece of wood.The word “axe” in the Hebrew is ma’atsad. It is a small sharp cutting instrument used for graving. This word also describes the “tongs” used by a silversmith. The only other place where this word is used is in the Bible is in Isaiah 44:12 where it describes the work of a smith, craftsman and artisan.

The heathens were not worshipping trees that they cut down, decorated and placed in the living room. This passage is not describing a Christmas tree. This was not “the customs of the peoples”. Their “custom” was to cut down trees, bring them to idol makers and have the idol makers create an idol from the trunk of the tree. See Isaiah 40:19-20 and 44:14-17. These scriptures are parallel passages that describe the making of idols. There is not an instance or example in the Bible of someone worshipping a decorated tree.

If you continue to read the Jeremiah 10 text you will read, “They are upright as the palm tree, but speak not, they must needs be borne, because they cannot go. Be not afraid of them; for they cannot do evil, neither also is it in them to do good” (vs. 5). Is this describing a Christmas tree or an idol made from wood?  This describes attributes idol worshippers sought to project onto their graven images.

Whether or not a Christmas tree distracts from the celebration of the birth of Jesus can be debated. Whether or not we should shop, buy presents, open gifts, attend office parties or hang stockings is up for scrutiny. What is not debatable is what the Bible says and what it means!

The Bible does not prohibit Christmas trees. In fact, the Bible is silent on the subject of Christmas trees! The Bible prohibits idolatry.

Celebrate Jesus for Christmas and thank God for Calvary’s Tree!

 

Advertisements

3 thoughts on ““The Christmas Tree Controversy”

  1. Bishop Alvin Palmer says:

    Greetings Bishop Teal, after reading you post on the Christmas tree controversy, I must say that you are absolutely correct. Jeremiah 10:1-5 has absolutely nothing to do with Christmas trees. You are also correct when you state that the Bible is silent on the subject of Christmas trees. However, checking back through the mists of biblical and secular history, eventually we come to the great-grandson of the patriarch Noah (of the great flood fame). There we find a man named Nimrod, founder of the Babylonian Empire, and known in Egypt as Osiris. (See Genesis 10:8-12). Nimrod was married to Semiramis who also happened to be his own mother! When Nimrod died in 2186 B.C. Semiramis claimed that he was a god, and that during the night an evergreen tree had sprung from the stump of a dead tree on the very spot where he had been buried. She said the tree was a symbol of new life, that Nimrod had been reborn and would return to visit this tree every year on the anniversary of his birth, to leave gifts under it. His birthday was at the time of the winter solstice, specifically on the 25th of December!
    A symbol is identified as the concrete representation of an idea or concept. If the real Christmas tree is a symbol of the false Babylonian religion established by Nimrod’s wife/mother, it cannot be a religious symbol of the followere of Christ.
    Although the Christmas tree has become accepted as a part of present-day culture and tradition, and warm fuzzy feeling, not withstanding,
    it cannot be connected with the truth of Jesus Christ.

    • Thank you for the historic context. I have been able to research more on the topic. We agree! Any ritual believers adhere to in the celebration of the birth of Jesus should be biblical, therefore acceptable to the Holy Spirit. We do not want to grieve the Spirit.

  2. Sonya says:

    Bishop, I really appreciate you exhortation on that. I have seen that come across my desk this year on several occasions and I began to wonder if the Christmas Tree was wrong or some form of idolatry. I questioned if the scripture was speaking of in the current day of that time then this tree couldn’t be related to the birth of Christ, unless he was speaking of future events. Then when I read custom of decorating the Christmas Tree on bible.com I knew again scripture has been read out of contect. Thanks for getting the truth out on this.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s